Miami · Fort Lauderdale · All Across Florida · Available 24/7 · Hablamos Espanol
A Miami appeals lawyer gives a person convicted of a crime a way to challenge the result, and an appeal or a post-conviction motion is often an individual’s hope to gain their freedom. A criminal appeal is similar to a civil appeal in many procedural ways. But the main issues that come up in criminal appeals are pre-trial rulings by the trial judge that denied the defendant a fair trial and errors in jury selection or instruction by the trial judge.
It’s critical that a Miami criminal defense lawyer who handles appeals has trial experience so they can easily identify those issues in the pre-trial hearing and trial transcripts to determine what went wrong. Judges are not infallible, and they can make incorrect rulings. This is especially true on the trial level. Great trial lawyers make great appellate lawyers and vice versa. Find out how The Kirlew Law Firm can help you in the appeals process or post-conviction.

An appeal is a judicial proceeding where a litigant or defendant can seek to reverse a ruling by a trial judge or a verdict entered by a jury. Almost always, appeals center on some decision made by the trial judge that denied the defendant a fair trial or prejudiced the defendant in such a way that it was impossible for him to receive a fair trial.
Rarely, the appellate courts will take a look at factual findings made by the trial court and render a ruling. A defendant convicted in a Florida criminal case has the right to a direct appeal, but the appeal begins only when a notice of appeal is filed on time.
The state court system is divided into four tiers on the state level – County Court, Circuit Court, District Court, and the State’s Supreme Court.
County Court is the people’s court. In criminal cases, County Court hears misdemeanors such as simple battery, petit theft, and DUI, among others.
A decision made by a County Court judge is appealed to a panel of Circuit Court judges chosen by the Chief Judge of the Circuit that the County Court is located. Circuit Court is the next tier in the court system. Circuit Court hears all manner of felonies from the possession of cocaine up to first-degree murder.
A decision by a Circuit Court judge is appealed to the District Courts of Appeal for that Circuit. There are six District Courts of Appeal in Florida. Decisions made by the District Courts of Appeal are appealed to the Florida Supreme Court. The Florida Supreme Court can be appealed to the United States Supreme Court if the decision rendered by the lower court was a matter of federal law.
In the federal court system, the appellate process works almost identical to the state court system. The trial court in the federal system is called the District Court. In the District Court, federal judges conduct trials or hear motions on constitutional issues such as improper search or illegally obtained confessions.
Decisions made by District Court judges are appealed to the Circuit Court of Appeals. Each District Court is assigned to a circuit based upon its geographic location. In Florida, our circuit court of appeal is the Eleventh Circuit located in Atlanta, Georgia. Decisions made by the Circuit Court of Appeals can be appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court.
We’ll set up a phone consultation to get to know you and your circumstances.
A post-conviction motion is a legal proceeding that allows for a person who has already been convicted and sentenced to seek a new trial. The hearings on these motions are heard in the same court, and often the same judge, as where the trial occurred. Generally, there are two primary scenarios in which someone who has already been convicted and sentenced can file a post-conviction motion:

Ineffective assistance of counsel is often the remedy used to seek relief in a post-conviction hearing. The argument is that the trial lawyer was so derelict and ineffective in their duties, that the Defendant was denied a fair trial through no fault of their own. Hiring a quality trial attorney is the best way to avoid a wrongful conviction.
But too often, bad lawyers get complicated cases and do a horrible job for their clients. That is where a quality Miami Post-Conviction Attorney, such as the Kirlew Law Firm, can review the trial record and challenge the result.
Newly discovered evidence is the second most common way to seek a new trial for a wrongfully convicted and sentenced Defendant. The standard is “the evidence could not have reasonably been discovered at the time of the trial through the exercise of due diligence”.
You often see this in DNA exoneration cases where some piece of evidence that wasn’t tested proves the Defendant did not commit the crime. You also see it in circumstances of witness recantation, witness collusion, or failure to identify and list exculpatory eyewitnesses.
A post-conviction motion must be filed within two years after the judgment and sentence become final, with a few exceptions.
The first step is to consult with Brian Kirlew, Esq., a Miami appeals attorney, to review your appeal case and the deadlines that apply. Quality representation and proper evaluation of your case are the only real way to know the viability of your appeal or post-conviction motion.
A Florida criminal appeal begins with a notice of appeal, and the deadline is short. The defendant must file the notice with the clerk of the trial court no later than 30 days after the written sentencing order is rendered, with copies to the state attorney and the attorney general. The notice can be filed at any time before that date.
A late notice can leave the appellate court without the power to hear the case. A defendant should hire a lawyer early so that they can review the trial file while the record is being assembled.
Federal criminal appeals run on a shorter clock than Florida appeals. A defendant convicted in federal court in Miami must file a notice of appeal with the district court within 14 days, which is less than half the time Florida allows. The district court may extend that period by up to 30 days, but only after finding excusable neglect or good cause.
A defendant who expects a prison sentence should have an appeals lawyer in place before sentencing. That lawyer can protect objections at the hearing and file the notice as soon as judgment is entered.
After the notice is filed, the trial court clerk has 50 days to prepare the record on appeal, which is the official file of what happened in the trial court. The clerk can’t send it until the designated transcripts are filed, so an appeal case moves only as fast as the transcripts are ordered.
The initial brief is due within 30 days after the record is sent or counsel is appointed, whichever is later. The brief identifies each error, points to the ruling in the transcript, and explains why the error harmed the defendant.
A Florida post-conviction motion must be signed under oath. The defendant swears to having read the motion, or having it read aloud, and to the truth of its facts. The motion must name the judgment under attack, say whether a plea or a trial produced it, state whether an appeal was taken, and briefly state the supporting facts.
A sentence that exceeds the legal limit can be challenged at any time. A federal prisoner files under 28 U.S.C. 2255 instead, and that motion has a one-year limit.
Florida appeal laws ask for more than a mistake at trial. A judgment or sentence may be reversed only when the error was prejudicial and properly preserved, meaning the error harmfully affected the result and the objection was raised in a timely manner in the trial court.
This rule puts the trial transcript at the center of every appeal case. The appeals lawyer reads it to find where trial counsel objected, what the judge ruled, and whether the objection covered the argument now being made. An objection never made can support an appeal only if the error was fundamental.
You should hire an appeals lawyer before the verdict or the day of sentencing. The 30-day state deadline and the 14-day federal deadline both start when the court acts.
Brian Kirlew is a board-certified trial lawyer who has tried 65 jury trials, and each one produced a transcript. Reading transcripts for error is the core of appellate work. He is also admitted to the Eleventh Circuit, so the same lawyer can handle a federal appeal from the Southern District of Florida.
An early consultation should settle which deadline applies, whether the needed objections were made, and whether a post-conviction motion fits better. To hire an appeals lawyer who has tried the kind of case you are appealing, contact The Kirlew Law Firm.
The fact is, there’s always something going on in a thriving metropolis like Miami. That means it’s easier than you might imagine to find yourself facing criminal charges. Given the dynamic nature of our city, it only makes sense for Brian Kirlew and his defense team to be flexible and responsive to the needs of his clients.
Our firm represents clients charged with any and all types of offenses in Miami and the greater South Florida area. The skills of an intelligent and experienced Miami criminal defense lawyer translate to all areas of criminal law. Therefore, we do not like to be bound by one or two particular areas as our “specialty.” We find defending against a broad spectrum of crimes to be more interesting and enjoyable to our practice.
Brian Kirlew, Esq. is experienced in defending all kinds of criminal felony and misdemeanor charges in the greater Miami area, including:
A: The cost for a lawyer to appeal a case depends on the length of the trial record, the number of issues to brief, and whether the case is in state or federal court. A longer transcript means more pages to read and cite. The fee is set in a written agreement before work begins and is separate from court charges.
A: An appeal in Florida costs a $300 filing fee when the notice is docketed in a district court of appeal, and an appeal from county court to circuit court in Miami-Dade carries a $281 fee. Copies of the record are billed at $1 per page plus a $2 certification fee, and court reporters charge separately for transcripts. These costs are in addition to the lawyer’s fee.
A: You generally can’t present new evidence on an appeal. The appellate court decides the appeal after a review of the complete record from the trial court, so evidence that was never part of that record isn’t considered. Facts that neither the defendant nor the lawyer knew at trial can be raised through a post-conviction motion, which has its own time limit.
A: You can stay out of jail during an appeal only if the trial court grants release, and release can’t take effect until the notice of appeal is filed. The request can be filed with the notice. When the state is the one appealing, an incarcerated defendant charged with a bailable offense must be released on their own recognizance unless the court finds good cause.
A: An appeal from a Miami-Dade felony conviction is heard by the Third District Court of Appeal, which serves the Eleventh and Sixteenth Judicial Circuits. Miami-Dade County makes up the Eleventh Judicial Circuit. A federal conviction entered in Miami goes to the Eleventh Circuit instead, which is a separate court that hears federal appeals from Florida, Georgia, and Alabama.
When you’re facing criminal charges in Miami, time is of the essence. It’s important that you have the proper legal representation to ensure that you get the best outcome possible from your trial. At the Kirlew Law Firm, you, your family, and your business are what matter most to us. We want to ensure that you enjoy every advantage that our thorough and collaborative approach to criminal defense has to offer.
Brian Kirlew is here to represent you. You can schedule your free phone consultation with our criminal defense lawyers today to begin building a sound defense strategy.
Committed to aggressive, personalized legal representation for criminal defense, white collar, federal, and family law matters throughout Florida since 2012.
888 S. Andrews Ave
Suite 201
Fort Lauderdale, FL 33316
© 2026 The Kirlew Law Firm, PLLC · 2103 Coral Way, Suite 401, Miami, FL 33145
Disclaimer | Site Map | Privacy Policy. Digital Marketing By: ![]()
*Images are obtained under license from Canva and other third-party stock image providers, with attribution included where required.